Universal Life Insurance, Part 1 – The Good, The Bad And The Ugly

Dave Frucella • May 6, 2019

Understanding Universal Life


Insurance The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly- Part 1

I’m going to give the conclusion of this painfully boring and very lengthy article: Don’t buy a Universal Life policy (aka Flexible Premium Adjustable Life, Variable Life, Indexed or Equity Universal Life) if you don’t understand the inner workings of the policy. It can cost you a fortune and leave you with no coverage and a possible big tax bill. Know ahead of time what can go wrong and proceed with caution. This is a contract you have to keep up with each and every year to include contact with your agent as to its progress. You can’t stick it in the drawer and forget about it. Your agent (who may disappear on you) is the key to the advice you will need down the road. Don’t depend on the insurance company for any assistance. Find an agent with experience and several years in the business and make them your new best friend.


Specifically, I am concerned how Indexed Universal Life contracts are promoted today (2019), as the “be all and end all” financial product with a pile of money awaiting you at retirement. I was around in the 1980’s when Universal Life was first introduced as “An Almost Perfect Policy” by major financial magazines. In the 1990’s and 2000’s, the number of class action lawsuits against insurance companies was staggering, just for the original Universal Life product alone.


There is limited percentage of financially savvy people that should consider buying a Universal Life policy. We recommend Universal Life in estate planning, business succession and other tax-planning situations. I’m OK with those that just want lifetime coverage with little expectation of cash value buildup. In those situations, we recommend paying the “guaranteed” premium vs. the “illustrated” premium (I’ll explain that later). In other words, regardless of whatever happens, they will have guaranteed coverage.


The above describes a very negative approach to Universal Life, however, the product is fine as long as those considering (and already own one) it understand the ins and outs as to how it works. I am troubled as to how it is sold. So the bottom line is, proceed with caution…


UNIVERSAL LIFE INSURANCE IS VERY CONFUSING

Now that you know the conclusion, let’s go back to the beginning…

When I want to know the time, I don’t care about the inner workings of the clock or how it produces the time, I just want the time. Unfortunately, this page is about the inner workings of Universal Life. It’s long and tedious. There’s just no other way around it. In my opinion, Universal Life is the most confusing product ever introduced by the insurance industry. If you are considering spending hundreds or thousands of dollars each year on this product, I suggest you read and re-read this page so that you know how this clock works. If you already have one of these contracts, this page will explain whether your policy is doing what it was set up to accomplish, or not. It will also guide you to ask your insurance company the right questions and get the accurate documents to assess the policy’s progress.


UNIVERSAL LIFE INSURANCE STARTED WITH HIGH RATES

What went wrong with Universal Life is that the product was introduced into a very high interest rate climate and was sold in a fashion that interest rates would stay high forever. I was kidded at that meeting 40 some years ago by some of my fellow agents when I asked the question, “What happens if interest rates go down?” The mind set in the late 1970’s was that interest rates would never go down. My wife and I bought our first house in 1980 and were thrilled that we got a 12% mortgage. How times change.


CONFUSION AND COMPLAINTS ABOUT UNIVERSAL LIFE INSURANCE

Looking back over those 40 years, what have the companies learned? As I mentioned above, the first thing we see is Universal Life produced more class-action suits that any other product the industry ever invented. It created so much confusion for the public that insurance departments throughout the country were overwhelmed with complaints. People had their life insurance cancelled when they thought they had lifetime coverage. In short, it was a disaster. The companies paid a gazillion dollars to settle class-action lawsuits to people who said they were misled by the companies and agents. I believe our industry is headed for a repeat performance with Indexed Universal Life.


UNIVERSAL LIFE INSURANCE WENT DOWNHILL

The main problem, as I see it, with Universal Life is that no one understands how the product works. It is nearly impossible to explain the policy’s mechanics. I think explaining the evolution of black holes in the universe is easier. To put this to the test, about 40 years ago, I met with a client who was a high-powered attorney in Washington DC. He negotiated contracts for major hotel chains and was one of the brightest people I ever met. So we sat down and I explained Universal Life. After I was done (about 15 minutes) he said he understood the concept. I turned the tables and asked him to explain it back to me. He couldn’t. So we went through it again and repeated the process. He tried again and failed. We gave it one more shot without success. I knew then either the product was doomed or I stunk as a salesman, probably both.



I’m going to attempt to explain the product and tell you why there is a very limited group that should consider purchasing this type of policy or one of its ugly stepsisters, Variable Life, Variable Universal Life and Indexed Universal Life. I will also, at no additional charge, advise those that already own this type of contract as to what they should do now.

By Kyle Taylor December 6, 2019
Best Life Insurance Companies: Who Are They? The answer to that question is: “it depends.”  If you are a non-smoker in good health, you should see most of the following companies towards the top of any worthwhile spreadsheet. If not, you may want to move on. Over 1,000 companies sell term life insurance so the focus here is the highest-rated companies offering the lowest prices. The listed companies are committed to the term marketplace. From time to time, we see other carriers move into and soon after quickly move out of this arena. It’s tough to be profitable and the company needs to know what it’s doing. These carriers have demonstrated their expertise. The current low-priced non-smoker leaders are: American General Life Insurance Company Banner Life Insurance Company John Hancock Life Insurance Company Pacific Life Protective Life Pruco Life Insurance Company (Prudential) William Penn Life Insurance Company (NY only) For Alternate Tobacco Users (Cigar, Pipe and Chewers), John Hancock or Pruco usually can’t be beat. For cigarette smokers, American General and Banner are usually in the top bracket. For non-smokers with weight problems, prices are all over the board, but Pruco has very generous limits. Family history problems are covered on the “Underwriting Guidelines” page. Best Life Insurance Rates: Call for Help Now I’ve only hit the high points here and can’t cover every situation. There are other companies not listed above that we use in special situations. If you have any health or lifestyle issues, I recommend you talk with an experienced agent (who is licensed in your state). If you’re talking with someone with an Internet company, ask him or her to fax you a copy of his or her individual license to sell in your state (not the company’s license). That way you know you’re not just talking with a telemarketer. A telemarketer’s only goal is to get your application started, regardless of company or underwriting criteria. This may seem harsh, but it can save you thousands of dollars. Questions? Comments? Suggestions? 1-800-542-5530
A woman is sitting at a desk holding a calculator.
By Dave Frucella October 27, 2019
Life insurance and life insurance underwriting are topics none of us like to think about much. But it’s a smart idea to have a policy. Today, the average funeral costs between $7,000 and $10,000, and you don’t want your family scrambling to come up with that money. Plus if anything happens with your house, car, […]
A woman is sitting on a couch writing on a clipboard.
By Dave Frucella September 27, 2019
When the business of life insurance began in 1759 in Philadelphia to help Presbyterian widows and orphans, there were no confusions or differences between term life insurance vs whole life insurance. Today, once you start looking for life insurance, all of the terms, rates, percentages, and explanations can get very confusing. And it’s for this […]
The numbers 12345 are made of wood and are on a red background
By Dave Frucella September 17, 2019
Research shows that 40% of Americans don’t have any form of life insurance policy in place. Does this include you? Buying life insurance is a wise route to take. However, it’s all too easy to stray off course. Life insurance policies are designed to provide financial security to your loved ones upon your death. The […]
A person is holding a wallet with money in it.
By Dave Frucella September 13, 2019
Research shows that 52% of Americans don’t get life insurance because they believe that it’s too expensive. However, there are many simple ways to find a cheaper life insurance policy — from using price comparison tools to giving up a dangerous hobby. Life insurance guarantees that your family will be provided for if you pass […]
A man and a woman are standing on a rock in the middle of the ocean holding hands.
By Dave Frucella June 7, 2019
This is Part 6 – You can start at the beginning – HERE «Part 5 Who Should Consider Buying A Universal Life Policy? Is Universal Life Insurance right for you? I have a problem when people call me and tell me they paying $50-100 per month for a Universal Life policy because they bought for […]
June 2, 2019
The Top Ten Life Insurance Questions We Are Asked Question 10 – What’s involved with buying a policy? Answer – There are many life insurance questions, but we’ll start with the application. It is a three-step process. First, there are forms to complete. Once that’s done, the paramedic will contact you to schedule your exam. The exam involves a health history along with a blood and urine specimen. The third part consists of the company contacting your doctor for your medical records. Once these details are done, the company will have a decision. Question 9 – How long does it take to get a policy? Answer – 4-6 weeks – can be sooner Question 8 – Does it cost me anything to apply? Answer – The company pays all the underwriting expenses. Your commitment is the time to take an exam. Question 7 – What is AmericaQuote’s recommendation as to which policy I should buy? Answer – We recommend buying the longest affordable rate guarantee from the highest-rated company. Question 6 – If my spouse and I apply together, can we get a discount? Answer – Not currently with most competitive carriers – the companies offered spouse discounts until about 2001. They found that practice to be unprofitable as rates continued to decline. A spousal rider is an option. Question 5 – What is AmericaQuote? How long have you been around? Answer – This is one of many good life insurance questions. Who are you dealing with? AmericaQuote was launched in 1996. AmericaQuote was the first interactive life insurance quotation service on the east coast and is the third-oldest insurance website on the Internet. We believe it is the most comprehensive life insurance web site on the entire Internet today. Of course, we’re prejudiced. Question 4 – How many companies do you represent? Answer – We keep the most competitive companies and plans in our database. It’s not necessary to show hundreds of company’s rates on the site, just the most competitive ones. Underwriting criteria is critical as it significantly affects the outcome. We don’t concern ourselves so much with a particular company’s health category. The key is knowing where you fit health-wise. Sometimes one company’s “Preferred” rate will be less expensive than another’s “Super-Preferred” rate. If you overshoot your estimation, the company and plan that is ultimately offered to you may not be best for your circumstance or pocketbook. We recommend you talk with an experienced agent, individually licensed in your state. If a company comes to the marketplace with a new low-cost product, we examine the company and its financial ratings before adding that product. Question 3 – Can I get a better deal elsewhere? Answer – The same policy in the same health category will have an equal premium, no matter where you buy it (even directly from the company). Your state regulates that. As mentioned above, to get the best price, first talk to an experienced agent, individually licensed in your state, who has access to several companies. They can assist in determining what health category you fit. Question 2 – How do I apply for the best rate? Answer – You don’t apply for a special rate; you apply for a policy. The company will let you know what health category you fit into and at what cost. Check out our Underwriting Guidelines page. The most asked question is: “If I apply and don’t qualify for the premium I’m expecting to pay, will the company make me another offer?" Answer – If you apply and for some reason don’t qualify for the health category you feel you deserve, the company will probably offer (assuming you’re insurable) you a different premium. You can accept or reject it. This, of course, can be frustrating if you think you fit in a better health category than the company is offering. Their rate also may be higher than a competing company in that same lower category. At that point, your offer would need to be shopped among other carriers. A realistic appraisal of your health before applying is critical to the right buying decision. This only covers some of the life insurance answers. There are probably fifty other life insurance questions one could ask. We have the answers and will be glad to discuss your situation if you wish. Questions? Comments? Suggestions? 1-800-542-5530
A man and a woman are standing on a rock in the middle of the ocean holding hands.
By Dave Frucella May 7, 2019
This is Part 5 – You can start at the beginning HERE About Your Universal Life Insurance Quote «Part 4 – Part 6» About Variable Life Insurance The concept is the same as above. Variable Life is a “bucket.” everything works the same with a major exception. In a Variable contract, you have more control […]
A man and a woman are standing on a rock in the middle of the ocean holding hands.
By Dave Frucella May 7, 2019
This is Part 4 – You can start at the beginning HERE Universal Life Insurance Guide & Information «Part 3 – Part 5» Back to 1980’s… The interest rate the company is paying you on your “bucket.” is the critical part. Let me digress for a minute back to the 1980’s and into the 1990’s […]
A man and a woman are standing on a rock in the middle of the ocean holding hands.
By Dave Frucella May 7, 2019
This is Part 3 – You can start at the beginning HERE Benefits & Failures of Universal Life Insurance «Part 2 – Part 4» “The Bucket” What I’m about to describe is the “chassis” of a Universal Life policy, whether a standard Universal Life contract, Variable Life or Indexed Universal Life. I want you to […]
A man and a woman are standing on a rock in the middle of the ocean holding hands.
By Dave Frucella May 7, 2019
This is Part 2 – You can start at the beginning HERE About Universal Life Insurance Policies History of Universal Life Insurance Over 40 years ago, I sat in a former employer’s class anxiously waiting for the product that was going to revolutionize the life insurance industry. It was called Universal Life. It was a […]
The numbers 12345 are made of wood and are on a red background
By Dave Frucella April 7, 2019
Because insurance premiums can vary widely (as much as 300-500%), you should always get quotes in writing from multiple respected companies. AmericaQuote represents America’s top insurance companies. When you fill out our Instant Life Insurance Quote form you will get multiple quotes from the companies that offer the best and
The numbers 12345 are made of wood and are on a red background
By Dave Frucella March 7, 2019
Are the companies you are comparing small subsidiaries of larger parent firms? This is a very important. Many large companies are forming alliances with smaller companies to sell specialty products, such as term and term-like insurance.
A person is writing in a notebook with a pen.
By Dave Frucella May 6, 2017
Which to Buy? The insurance industry is second only to the legal industry in making things more complicated than they need to be. There are really just two kinds of life insurance: permanent and term. Variations of each type exist, but let’s define “Perm” and “Term” as a starting place.
A man and a woman are standing next to each other in the snow holding snow shovels.
By Dave Frucella May 5, 2017
Life Insurance Sales Tactics – The Bait & Switch Watch Out for the Life Insurance Bait and Switch How I was trained to sell life insurance in the early 1970s: I dialed the phone from 6:00–8:00 p.m. every night looking for potential customers. My sales manager told me, “Don’t cover any details—just get the appointment.” […]
A person is putting a coin into a piggy bank.
By Dave Frucella May 5, 2017
How To Save Money When Switching Life Insurance Companies One well-known insurance company has flooded the airwaves with this promise: “Give us 15 minutes and we may be able to save you 15 percent on your car insurance.”
Two men are playing frisbee in a grassy field.
By Dave Frucella May 5, 2017
I am drawing special attention to the phrase “Guaranteed Renewable” in life insurance contracts because it is easy to misinterpret. When heard in a TV commercial: “Our policies’ rates are guaranteed for the first 20 years and are guaranteed renewable thereafter to age 100”—or something similar.
No Exam Life Insurance
By Dave Frucella May 5, 2017
When I fly out of Charlotte's airport, I don’t use valet parking. It’s convenient but very expensive. Instead, I leave my car in the inexpensive satellite lot and take a free shuttle to the terminal. One is easy and very expensive, the other is a little bit of trouble but less expensive.
A man is giving a piece of paper to a woman.
By Dave Frucella May 5, 2017
My slow awakening may save you piles of money. In 1974, I went to work for a major insurance company. They offered the usual package of benefits - health, dental and life insurance. They gave me one times my salary for free and I could buy up to four times additional
More Posts