Jul 04 2025 16:00

Watch Out For The Life Insurance Bait and Switch

David Frucella

Life Insurance Sales Tactics – The Bait & Switch

Watch Out for the Life Insurance Bait and Switch

How I was trained to sell life insurance in the early 1970s: I dialed the phone from 6:00–8:00 p.m. every night looking for potential customers. My sales manager told me, “Don’t cover any details—just get the appointment.” Once I set an appointment, my manager would say, “Don’t cover too many details—just get a signed application and schedule a medical exam.”

Those initial commitments represent classic sales training technique: A series of small “Yesses” leading to the final “Yes.” Saying “Yes” to an appointment and “Yes” to an application and “Yes” to a medical exam makes the last “Yes”—writing the check—seem less painful. In small steps, the customer is getting committed and invested in buying from you without even knowing it. The chances of the customer backing out get lower with each “Yes.”

The Bait: Tell You a Good Rate

The Bait and Switch when buying life insurance is alive and well today. Many Internet companies employ the same tactic. If you call for a quote, you may be talking a telemarketer who is following a script. They are paid about $10 per hour, and their goal is to quote you the best possible rate and get you to commit to taking a medical exam. The impression left with the caller is, “you have an excellent chance to get that low rate.

That’s the bait—the incremental promise of a secure life insurance policy to protect your family.

The Switch: They Can’t Get That Rate

Then comes the switch. After the medical exam, you wait several weeks to get the company’s quote for your insurance. And it will almost always be more than you were led to believe: “We tried to get the rate we discussed, but it just didn’t work out due to (x, y, or z). But I have good news—the company can get the policy we discussed at a different rate which I think you should take.” And that “different rate” is, of course, higher.

Now the frustrated customer has four choices:

That same “bait and switch” technique is still going on in the life insurance industry today. If you get called by a “life insurance salesperson” you need first to determine if he or she is actually a licensed-in-your-state insurance professional—or a telemarketer being paid $10 per hour to collect contacts which are then sold to insurance brokers for “follow up.”

How to Avoid the Bait & Switch

Be wary. Deal only with insurance salespeople or web sites who treat you with respect.
Questions? Comments? Suggestions? 1-800-542-5530 – admin@americaquote.com